This thesis examines how urban planning knowledge circulates transnationally through state-led mechanisms, focusing on China–Singapore government-to-government (G2G) collaborations. In contrast to literature that emphasizes market-driven or city-to-city policy mobility, this study foregrounds the strategic role of national governments, statutory institutions, and multi-level governance in shaping how planning models are transferred, adapted, and occasionally re-exported. At the centre of this analysis is the “Singapore Model”, a modular and institutionally coordinated planning framework that blends long-term vision with technocratic governance. Rather than treating this model as a fixed blueprint, the study investigates how its components are selectively mobilized and reinterpreted within China’s unique political and planning environment. Guided by three research questions and corresponding hypotheses, the study adopts a comparative case study approach, focusing on two flagship projects: Suzhou Industrial Park (SIP) and the Tianjin Eco-City (SSTEC). Drawing on extensive fieldwork, interviews with key actors, analysis, the research traces both explicit and tacit knowledge flows, as well as the evolving roles of different levels of government. Findings reveal divergent trajectories: SIP enabled deeper institutional embedding and knowledge spillovers, while SSTEC’s outcomes were more fragmented, despite strong discursive frameworks. These differences reflect not only the nature of the imported model, but also local capacities, agency, and institutional alignment. The thesis makes four contributions: (1) it refines the concept of modular urban models by analysing how components are selectively adapted; (2) it advances the study of transnational knowledge transfer by emphasizing governance structures and transfer mechanisms; (3) it highlights Asia’s emerging role as a site of knowledge production and circulation, challenging traditional Global North–South knowledge transfer narratives; and (4) it contributes methodologically by adopting a process-oriented and multi-scalar approach to analysing planning knowledge transfer through institutional processes.
Questa tesi esamina come le conoscenze urbanistiche circolino a livello transnazionale attraverso meccanismi guidati dallo Stato, con un focus sulle collaborazioni intergovernative tra Cina e Singapore. In contrasto con la letteratura esistente, che enfatizza la mobilità delle politiche guidata dal mercato o da connessioni tra città, questo studio mette in primo piano il ruolo strategico dei governi nazionali, delle istituzioni statali e dei sistemi di governance multilivello nel modellare il trasferimento, l’adattamento e, in alcuni casi, la ri-esportazione dei modelli di pianificazione urbana. Al centro dell’analisi si trova il cosiddetto “Modello Singapore”, un sistema di pianificazione modulare e coordinato istituzionalmente che combina una visione strategica di lungo periodo con una governance tecnocratica. Piuttosto che considerare questo modello come una struttura definita, lo studio indaga come i suoi componenti vengano mobilitati e reinterpretati selettivamente all’interno dello specific contesto politico e pianificatorio unico della Cina. Guidata da tre domande di ricerca e dalle relative ipotesi, la tesi adotta un approccio comparativo basato su due casi emblematici: il Suzhou Industrial Park (SIP) e la Tianjin Eco-City (SSTEC). Basandosi su un ampio lavoro sul campo, interviste con attori chiave e analisi delle politiche e dello spazio urbano, la ricerca traccia i trasferimenti di conoscenza sia esplicita che tacita, osservando l’evoluzione del ruolo dei diversi livelli di governo. I risultati evidenziano traiettorie divergenti: SIP ha favorito un radicamento istituzionale più profondo e la diffusione secondaria di conoscenze, mentre gli esiti di SSTEC si sono rivelati più frammentati, nonostante un forte impianto narrativo. Queste differenze riflettono non solo la natura del modello importato, ma anche le capacità locali, l’agenzia strategica e l’allineamento istituzionale. La tesi apporta quattro contributi: (1) affina il concetto di modelli urbani modulari, analizzando come i singoli componenti vengano adattati selettivamente; (2) arricchisce gli studi sul trasferimento di conoscenze transnazionali, evidenziando il ruolo delle strutture di governance e dei meccanismi di trasferimento; (3) mette in luce il ruolo emergente dell’Asia come produttore e diffusore di conoscenza urbanistica, sfidando le narrazioni tradizionali di trasferimento di conoscenza dal Nord al Sud Globale; e (4) contribuisce metodologicamente adottando un approccio orientato ai processi e multi-scalare per analizzare il trasferimento della conoscenza pianificatoria attraverso processi istituzionali.
The role of governments in the circulation of urban models and knowledge: the case of China-Singapore collaboration projects
Li, Siyuan
2026
Abstract
This thesis examines how urban planning knowledge circulates transnationally through state-led mechanisms, focusing on China–Singapore government-to-government (G2G) collaborations. In contrast to literature that emphasizes market-driven or city-to-city policy mobility, this study foregrounds the strategic role of national governments, statutory institutions, and multi-level governance in shaping how planning models are transferred, adapted, and occasionally re-exported. At the centre of this analysis is the “Singapore Model”, a modular and institutionally coordinated planning framework that blends long-term vision with technocratic governance. Rather than treating this model as a fixed blueprint, the study investigates how its components are selectively mobilized and reinterpreted within China’s unique political and planning environment. Guided by three research questions and corresponding hypotheses, the study adopts a comparative case study approach, focusing on two flagship projects: Suzhou Industrial Park (SIP) and the Tianjin Eco-City (SSTEC). Drawing on extensive fieldwork, interviews with key actors, analysis, the research traces both explicit and tacit knowledge flows, as well as the evolving roles of different levels of government. Findings reveal divergent trajectories: SIP enabled deeper institutional embedding and knowledge spillovers, while SSTEC’s outcomes were more fragmented, despite strong discursive frameworks. These differences reflect not only the nature of the imported model, but also local capacities, agency, and institutional alignment. The thesis makes four contributions: (1) it refines the concept of modular urban models by analysing how components are selectively adapted; (2) it advances the study of transnational knowledge transfer by emphasizing governance structures and transfer mechanisms; (3) it highlights Asia’s emerging role as a site of knowledge production and circulation, challenging traditional Global North–South knowledge transfer narratives; and (4) it contributes methodologically by adopting a process-oriented and multi-scalar approach to analysing planning knowledge transfer through institutional processes.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Li_Thesis.pdf
non disponibili
Licenza:
Tutti i diritti riservati
Dimensione
84.08 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
84.08 MB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14242/384803
URN:NBN:IT:POLIMI-384803