Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) are increasingly deployed in domains where computational decisions interact with physical processes, software components, humans, and surrounding environments. As CPS autonomy and societal relevance increase, ethical concerns, including privacy, security, transparency, fairness, and trust, must be addressed alongside functional and quality requirements. However, translating these high-level ethical concerns into concrete engineering activities remains a significant challenge. While existing research establishes important foundations for ethical reasoning in CPS, the processes of identifying ethics-based requirements, integrating them into system design, assessing their impact on observable behavior, and testing their fulfillment are frequently addressed in isolation. This thesis examines how ethical aspects can be treated as first-class concerns in CPS engineering through different stages of the software development process. First, a Grounded Theory Literature Review method is conducted to identify and structure ethics-based requirements within the CPS literature. The analysis of 56 publications results in a catalog of 58 ethics-based concepts, interconnected by 156 interdependencies, with privacy, security, transparency, fairness, and trust identified as the most prominent concerns. Second, the thesis explores how selected requirements inform CPS design by organizing privacy, security, and transparency into design objectives and techniques, applying these to a patient monitoring scenario. This design perspective is complemented by a quantitative evaluation examining how privacy-related overhead affects the performance of different coordination strategies under varying workload conditions. Third, the thesis investigates human perceptions of ethical behavior in self-driving cars through a study with 60 participants and simulated driving scenarios. The findings indicate that ethical judgments are context-dependent and that functional safety alone is insufficient to establish ethical acceptability. Fourth, physical privacy is operationalized as a measurable testing objective for mobile robots, and a search-based testing approach is developed to generate human-behavior configurations that lead to persistent privacy violations during robotic navigation. The evaluation does not establish a consistent advantage over random search across the three examined scenarios, highlighting the influence of scenario characteristics on the results. Overall, the thesis contributes to ethics-aware CPS engineering by identifying and structuring ethics-based requirements and investigating their implications for system design, human assessment, and automated testing. By providing evidence, models, and techniques across these complementary areas, the thesis contributes toward the development of Cyber-Physical Ethical Systems (CPES), in which ethical concerns are considered alongside the cyber and physical dimensions of these systems.
Ethical Aspects of Cyber-Physical Systems
KURKCHI, YELYZAVETA
2026
Abstract
Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) are increasingly deployed in domains where computational decisions interact with physical processes, software components, humans, and surrounding environments. As CPS autonomy and societal relevance increase, ethical concerns, including privacy, security, transparency, fairness, and trust, must be addressed alongside functional and quality requirements. However, translating these high-level ethical concerns into concrete engineering activities remains a significant challenge. While existing research establishes important foundations for ethical reasoning in CPS, the processes of identifying ethics-based requirements, integrating them into system design, assessing their impact on observable behavior, and testing their fulfillment are frequently addressed in isolation. This thesis examines how ethical aspects can be treated as first-class concerns in CPS engineering through different stages of the software development process. First, a Grounded Theory Literature Review method is conducted to identify and structure ethics-based requirements within the CPS literature. The analysis of 56 publications results in a catalog of 58 ethics-based concepts, interconnected by 156 interdependencies, with privacy, security, transparency, fairness, and trust identified as the most prominent concerns. Second, the thesis explores how selected requirements inform CPS design by organizing privacy, security, and transparency into design objectives and techniques, applying these to a patient monitoring scenario. This design perspective is complemented by a quantitative evaluation examining how privacy-related overhead affects the performance of different coordination strategies under varying workload conditions. Third, the thesis investigates human perceptions of ethical behavior in self-driving cars through a study with 60 participants and simulated driving scenarios. The findings indicate that ethical judgments are context-dependent and that functional safety alone is insufficient to establish ethical acceptability. Fourth, physical privacy is operationalized as a measurable testing objective for mobile robots, and a search-based testing approach is developed to generate human-behavior configurations that lead to persistent privacy violations during robotic navigation. The evaluation does not establish a consistent advantage over random search across the three examined scenarios, highlighting the influence of scenario characteristics on the results. Overall, the thesis contributes to ethics-aware CPS engineering by identifying and structuring ethics-based requirements and investigating their implications for system design, human assessment, and automated testing. By providing evidence, models, and techniques across these complementary areas, the thesis contributes toward the development of Cyber-Physical Ethical Systems (CPES), in which ethical concerns are considered alongside the cyber and physical dimensions of these systems.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_PhDThesis_Kurkchi.pdf
accesso aperto
Licenza:
Tutti i diritti riservati
Dimensione
5.91 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
5.91 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14242/385728
URN:NBN:IT:GSSI-385728