Climate change is profoundly reshaping the environmental conditions under which grapevines (Vitis vinifera L.) are cultivated, particularly in Mediterranean regions, which have been identified as hotspots of warming and desertification. Rising temperatures altered precipitation patterns, and increased frequency of heat waves and drought events threaten both vine physiology and grape quality, accelerating phenological development, disrupting the balance between sugars and acidity, and compromising the accumulation of berry secondary metabolites such as anthocyanins, flavonols, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). In response to these challenges, short term canopy management techniques that manipulate the source sink balance have gained attention as flexible and cost effective strategies to mitigate climate induced stress while preserving or enhancing berry quality. Among these, apical leaf removal and crop load adjustment have emerged as promising approaches, although their effectiveness is known to vary significantly depending on application timing, water availability, and seasonal climatic conditions. The main objective of this PhD project was to evaluate the physiological and fruit quality responses of grapevines to canopy manipulation, with a specific focus on understanding how the interaction between source limitation, vine water status, and temperature regime modulates berry ripening dynamics and composition. More specifically, the project was structured around three experiments: Experiment 1 and 2 investigated the combined effects of apical leaf removal and water availability by quantifying vine water status, leaf gas exchange, leaf area, and berry quality. Experiment 3 transferred this technique to a commercial vineyard to assess its real-world feasibility, again measuring both physiological and fruit quality parameters. Experiment 4, in turn, examined the combined effect of crop load and temperature regime, with a particular emphasis on ripening dynamics and fruit quality, alongside leaf gas exchange and vegetative traits. Apical leaf removal in potted Sangiovese grapevines subjected to either water deficit or well-watered conditions induced photosynthetic compensation at the single-leaf level, with defoliated vines exhibiting significantly higher net photosynthesis than control vines. The effect on vine water status was, however, transient: both early (ELR) and late apical leaf removal (LLR) treatments improved stem water potential only temporarily, and the cumulative vine transpiration was not consistently reduced, suggesting that the mitigation of water stress through leaf removal is limited and short lived. From a qualitative perspective, pre-veraison apical leaf removal delayed harvest more effectively under water deficit conditions, whereas when applied after veraison it was more effective under well watered conditions. When applied before veraison apical leaf removal reduced berry total anthocyanin accumulation and shifted the hydroxylation pattern toward di hydroxylated forms, while increasing free VOCs, particularly volatile phenols and monoterpenes. In contrast, post-veraison apical leaf removal preserved anthocyanin levels and enhanced berry glycosylated monoterpenes and C13 norisoprenoids. These findings highlighted that the outcome of this technique is highly dependent on both the timing of application and the vine water status. Specifically, deficit irrigation amplifying the effects of early defoliation on ripening delay and aromatic composition, whereas late season source limitation can selectively improve aroma precursors without compromising phenolic ripening. Extending the investigation to a Sangiovese commercial vineyard setting over two consecutive seasons, the results confirmed that apical leaf removal significantly induced photosynthetic compensation, and transient improvement of vine water status but the impact on berry ripening delay was inconsistent across years. In the warmer and drier year, ELR and LLR delayed harvest by one week, whereas in the cooler and wetter year, no significant delay was observed. Notably, early apical leaf removal reduced pruning weight without decreasing fruit yield, resulting in a higher Ravaz index, suggesting a preferential allocation of carbon toward berries at the expense of reserve accumulation in perennial organs. Berry anthocyanins concentration was negatively affected by leaf removal only in the warmer year, whereas flavonols were primarily driven by interannual climatic variability rather than by treatments. Although total glycosylated VOCs were not significantly modified by defoliation, the application timing of apical leaf removal selectively affected specific volatile classes: when applied in pre-veraison increased C13 norisoprenoids by 33%, whereas after veraison enhanced linalool content by 57%. These results demonstrated that the effectiveness of apical leaf removal in commercial conditions is highly context dependent and strongly modulated by seasonal climate, yet the technique remains valuable for its ability to selectively modulate important aroma compounds. The interaction between crop load manipulation and enhanced temperature regime, was tested on Sauvignon blanc in Marlborough, New Zealand. Passive temperature elevation frames increased maximum daily temperature by an average of 2.3°C during the ripening period, but their effect on leaf gas exchange where inconsistent. On the contrary basal leaf SPAD values increased under warming and decreased under high crop load, suggesting altered source sink dynamics and leaf senescence patterns. Notably, additional warming consistently increased berry and wine pH by reducing malic acid concentration, regardless of crop load, confirming that elevated temperatures directly degrade berry acidity. Furthermore, wine thiols resulted decreased by -30.8% under elevated temperature, indicating a possible threaten for Sauvignon varietal aroma under increasing temperature scenario. Crop load manipulation, on the other hand, effectively anticipated berry harvest by 13 days in the reduced crop load vines compared to full crop load ones and altered wine potassium concentration and total phenols. However, crop load adjustment did not compensate for warming induced acidity loss, indicating that source manipulation alone cannot counteract the negative effects of rising temperatures on grape acidity. These findings underscored that while crop load effectively modulates ripening kinetics and phenolic profiles, it does not mitigate the detrimental effects of warming on acidity and wine thiols, and integrated strategies combining multiple approaches are therefore necessary. Taken together, the results obtained in this PhD project provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the potential and limitations of canopy manipulation as a climate adaptation strategy in viticulture.
Canopy management techniques to mitigate the effect of Climate Change in grapevine while enhancing grape berry quality
TOSI, VINCENZO
2026
Abstract
Climate change is profoundly reshaping the environmental conditions under which grapevines (Vitis vinifera L.) are cultivated, particularly in Mediterranean regions, which have been identified as hotspots of warming and desertification. Rising temperatures altered precipitation patterns, and increased frequency of heat waves and drought events threaten both vine physiology and grape quality, accelerating phenological development, disrupting the balance between sugars and acidity, and compromising the accumulation of berry secondary metabolites such as anthocyanins, flavonols, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). In response to these challenges, short term canopy management techniques that manipulate the source sink balance have gained attention as flexible and cost effective strategies to mitigate climate induced stress while preserving or enhancing berry quality. Among these, apical leaf removal and crop load adjustment have emerged as promising approaches, although their effectiveness is known to vary significantly depending on application timing, water availability, and seasonal climatic conditions. The main objective of this PhD project was to evaluate the physiological and fruit quality responses of grapevines to canopy manipulation, with a specific focus on understanding how the interaction between source limitation, vine water status, and temperature regime modulates berry ripening dynamics and composition. More specifically, the project was structured around three experiments: Experiment 1 and 2 investigated the combined effects of apical leaf removal and water availability by quantifying vine water status, leaf gas exchange, leaf area, and berry quality. Experiment 3 transferred this technique to a commercial vineyard to assess its real-world feasibility, again measuring both physiological and fruit quality parameters. Experiment 4, in turn, examined the combined effect of crop load and temperature regime, with a particular emphasis on ripening dynamics and fruit quality, alongside leaf gas exchange and vegetative traits. Apical leaf removal in potted Sangiovese grapevines subjected to either water deficit or well-watered conditions induced photosynthetic compensation at the single-leaf level, with defoliated vines exhibiting significantly higher net photosynthesis than control vines. The effect on vine water status was, however, transient: both early (ELR) and late apical leaf removal (LLR) treatments improved stem water potential only temporarily, and the cumulative vine transpiration was not consistently reduced, suggesting that the mitigation of water stress through leaf removal is limited and short lived. From a qualitative perspective, pre-veraison apical leaf removal delayed harvest more effectively under water deficit conditions, whereas when applied after veraison it was more effective under well watered conditions. When applied before veraison apical leaf removal reduced berry total anthocyanin accumulation and shifted the hydroxylation pattern toward di hydroxylated forms, while increasing free VOCs, particularly volatile phenols and monoterpenes. In contrast, post-veraison apical leaf removal preserved anthocyanin levels and enhanced berry glycosylated monoterpenes and C13 norisoprenoids. These findings highlighted that the outcome of this technique is highly dependent on both the timing of application and the vine water status. Specifically, deficit irrigation amplifying the effects of early defoliation on ripening delay and aromatic composition, whereas late season source limitation can selectively improve aroma precursors without compromising phenolic ripening. Extending the investigation to a Sangiovese commercial vineyard setting over two consecutive seasons, the results confirmed that apical leaf removal significantly induced photosynthetic compensation, and transient improvement of vine water status but the impact on berry ripening delay was inconsistent across years. In the warmer and drier year, ELR and LLR delayed harvest by one week, whereas in the cooler and wetter year, no significant delay was observed. Notably, early apical leaf removal reduced pruning weight without decreasing fruit yield, resulting in a higher Ravaz index, suggesting a preferential allocation of carbon toward berries at the expense of reserve accumulation in perennial organs. Berry anthocyanins concentration was negatively affected by leaf removal only in the warmer year, whereas flavonols were primarily driven by interannual climatic variability rather than by treatments. Although total glycosylated VOCs were not significantly modified by defoliation, the application timing of apical leaf removal selectively affected specific volatile classes: when applied in pre-veraison increased C13 norisoprenoids by 33%, whereas after veraison enhanced linalool content by 57%. These results demonstrated that the effectiveness of apical leaf removal in commercial conditions is highly context dependent and strongly modulated by seasonal climate, yet the technique remains valuable for its ability to selectively modulate important aroma compounds. The interaction between crop load manipulation and enhanced temperature regime, was tested on Sauvignon blanc in Marlborough, New Zealand. Passive temperature elevation frames increased maximum daily temperature by an average of 2.3°C during the ripening period, but their effect on leaf gas exchange where inconsistent. On the contrary basal leaf SPAD values increased under warming and decreased under high crop load, suggesting altered source sink dynamics and leaf senescence patterns. Notably, additional warming consistently increased berry and wine pH by reducing malic acid concentration, regardless of crop load, confirming that elevated temperatures directly degrade berry acidity. Furthermore, wine thiols resulted decreased by -30.8% under elevated temperature, indicating a possible threaten for Sauvignon varietal aroma under increasing temperature scenario. Crop load manipulation, on the other hand, effectively anticipated berry harvest by 13 days in the reduced crop load vines compared to full crop load ones and altered wine potassium concentration and total phenols. However, crop load adjustment did not compensate for warming induced acidity loss, indicating that source manipulation alone cannot counteract the negative effects of rising temperatures on grape acidity. These findings underscored that while crop load effectively modulates ripening kinetics and phenolic profiles, it does not mitigate the detrimental effects of warming on acidity and wine thiols, and integrated strategies combining multiple approaches are therefore necessary. Taken together, the results obtained in this PhD project provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the potential and limitations of canopy manipulation as a climate adaptation strategy in viticulture.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tosi_PhD_Thesis.pdf
embargo fino al 27/10/2029
Licenza:
Creative Commons
Dimensione
5.02 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
5.02 MB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14242/385826
URN:NBN:IT:UNIPI-385826