The thesis proposes a mixed institutional response to the uncertainties surrounding, in the EU, unauthorized uses of medicines, i.e., off-label and compassionate uses. It combines a reinterpretation of civil liability rules in light of the precautionary principle, complemented by a proportional liability model, with a no-fault plan, funded by general taxation and the industry. Both are integrated into a mandatory, non-binding ADR scheme. The thesis develops in three parts. First, the thesis explores EU pharmaceutical regulation, under which off-label uses are legal but represent a regulatory grey area between medical practice and research, where the levels of protection of patients’ health and legal certainty for health actors are low. Secondly, the thesis considers the potential contribution of civil liability rules, i.e., courts, to the regulation of off-label uses in the EU, France, and Italy. It highlights that, through an incremental process of trial and error, EU and national courts are adapting civil liability rules and categories (e.g., fault, product defectiveness, and causation) to tackle uncertain pharmaceutical and vaccinal risks, using the language and the methodology of the precautionary principle. When fully and correctly developed, this approach can promote victims' compensation, incentivize correct practices on the part of health actors (i.e., physicians, manufacturers, and regulators), and educate these latter. Thirdly, the role of a no-fault plan is appraised vis-à-vis those unknown risks that cannot and should not fall under the scope of civil liability. The thesis also considers how the French and the Italian legal systems are using and could use ADR systems to improve access to justice. A well-designed ADR mechanism would let civil liability realize its full potential and avoid distortionary distributive effects. This complex institutional arrangement can thus foster a fair and efficient allocation of uncertain and unknown pharmaceutical risks among the involved stakeholders. The same analysis is conducted about compassionate use programs. Conclusions sum up the outcome of the research and argue for its relevance in other regulatory grey areas. They also contend that such a proposal could contribute to reconciling science and democracy, i.e., experts’ accountability from below and rigorous scientific scrutiny over their decisions, thus overcoming the rigid contrast between scientific “populists” and “anti-populists” Western countries are currently experiencing.

Civil liability and Regulation in The European Market for Unauthorized Uses of Medicines

PARZIALE, ANDREA
2019

Abstract

The thesis proposes a mixed institutional response to the uncertainties surrounding, in the EU, unauthorized uses of medicines, i.e., off-label and compassionate uses. It combines a reinterpretation of civil liability rules in light of the precautionary principle, complemented by a proportional liability model, with a no-fault plan, funded by general taxation and the industry. Both are integrated into a mandatory, non-binding ADR scheme. The thesis develops in three parts. First, the thesis explores EU pharmaceutical regulation, under which off-label uses are legal but represent a regulatory grey area between medical practice and research, where the levels of protection of patients’ health and legal certainty for health actors are low. Secondly, the thesis considers the potential contribution of civil liability rules, i.e., courts, to the regulation of off-label uses in the EU, France, and Italy. It highlights that, through an incremental process of trial and error, EU and national courts are adapting civil liability rules and categories (e.g., fault, product defectiveness, and causation) to tackle uncertain pharmaceutical and vaccinal risks, using the language and the methodology of the precautionary principle. When fully and correctly developed, this approach can promote victims' compensation, incentivize correct practices on the part of health actors (i.e., physicians, manufacturers, and regulators), and educate these latter. Thirdly, the role of a no-fault plan is appraised vis-à-vis those unknown risks that cannot and should not fall under the scope of civil liability. The thesis also considers how the French and the Italian legal systems are using and could use ADR systems to improve access to justice. A well-designed ADR mechanism would let civil liability realize its full potential and avoid distortionary distributive effects. This complex institutional arrangement can thus foster a fair and efficient allocation of uncertain and unknown pharmaceutical risks among the involved stakeholders. The same analysis is conducted about compassionate use programs. Conclusions sum up the outcome of the research and argue for its relevance in other regulatory grey areas. They also contend that such a proposal could contribute to reconciling science and democracy, i.e., experts’ accountability from below and rigorous scientific scrutiny over their decisions, thus overcoming the rigid contrast between scientific “populists” and “anti-populists” Western countries are currently experiencing.
25-feb-2019
Italiano
ADR Systems.
Civil Liability
Class Actions
Comparative Law
Compassionate Uses
EU Law
EU Pharmaceutical Regulation
French Law
Italian Law
Law & Economics
Law and Health
Liability for Dangerous Activities
Mass Tort Litigation
Medical Liability
No-fault Plans
Off-label Uses
Potential Risks
Precautionary Principle
Product Liability
Public Health
State Liability
Uncertain Causation
Unknown Risks
COMANDE', GIOVANNI
PONZANELLI, GIULIO
PALMERINI, ERICA
PARDOLESI, ROBERTO
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Andrea_Parziale_PhD_Thesis.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Altro materiale allegato
Dimensione 2.56 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
2.56 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14242/147355
Il codice NBN di questa tesi è URN:NBN:IT:SSSUP-147355