ABSTRACT, ENGLISH VERSION THE DISSERTATION EXAMINES THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD AS A HISTORICALLY DETERMINED FORM OF RATIONALITY AND AS A PEDAGOGICAL RESOURCE FOR PHYSICS EDUCATION, INTEGRATING PERSPECTIVES FROM THE HISTORY OF SCIENCE, EPISTEMOLOGY, AND EDUCATIONAL SCIENCES. THE AIM IS TO SHOW HOW THE HISTORICAL RECONSTRUCTION OF MODELS OF KNOWLEDGE MAKES IT POSSIBLE TO UNDERSTAND THE DEEP STRUCTURES OF COGNITIVE PROCESSES AND TO GUIDE INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN TOWARD GENUINELY INQUIRY-BASED EDUCATIONAL PRACTICES. THE FIRST CHAPTER RECONSTRUCTS THE GENEALOGY OF THE MAIN FORMS OF SCIENTIFIC RATIONALITY, FROM GRECO-HELLENISTIC ANTIQUITY TO MODERN SCIENCE AND CONTEMPORARY EPISTEMOLOGICAL PLURALISM, ANALYZING DIFFERENT WAYS OF ARTICULATING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN OBSERVATION, MODELING, FORMALIZATION, AND THEORETICAL JUSTIFICATION. THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD THUS EMERGES AS THE OUTCOME OF CONCEPTUAL AND ONTOLOGICAL TRANSFORMATIONS, RATHER THAN AS A NEUTRAL AND TIMELESS PROCEDURE. THE SECOND CHAPTER EXAMINES THE MAIN TRADITIONS OF SCIENCE EDUCATION IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY, FROM DEWEY TO BRUNER, INTERPRETING THEM AS MODELS OF EDUCATIONAL RATIONALITY GROUNDED IN THE ACTIVE AND SOCIALLY MEDIATED CONSTRUCTION OF KNOWLEDGE. WITHIN THIS FRAMEWORK, THE MODELS OF IBSE, MER, AND MEDS ARE DISCUSSED AS INTEGRATIVE APPROACHES TO INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN. THE THIRD CHAPTER ANALYZES PHYSICS LABORATORY ACTIVITIES DESIGNED ACCORDING TO INQUIRY- AND MODELING-BASED APPROACHES, SHOWING HOW HISTORICALLY ESTABLISHED EPISTEMIC OPERATIONS,PROBLEMATIZATION, OBSERVATION, IDEALIZATION, MODELING, FORMALIZATION, AND THE TESTING AND REVISION OF HYPOTHESES, RE-EMERGE IN STUDENTS’ LEARNING PROCESSES. THE DISSERTATION ARGUES THAT SCIENCE EDUCATION AND THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE SHARE HOMOLOGOUS COGNITIVE ARCHITECTURES, ALSO ROOTED IN THE PHYLOGENESIS OF THE HUMAN MIND, AND PROPOSES A CONCEPTION OF PHYSICS TEACHING AS EDUCATION IN CRITICAL RATIONALITY.
LA TESI ANALIZZA IL METODO SCIENTIFICO COME FORMA STORICAMENTE DETERMINATA DI RAZIONALITÀ E COME RISORSA PEDAGOGICA PER LA DIDATTICA DELLA FISICA, INTEGRANDO PROSPETTIVE DI STORIA DELLA SCIENZA, EPISTEMOLOGIA E SCIENZE DELL’EDUCAZIONE. L’OBIETTIVO È MOSTRARE COME LA RICOSTRUZIONE STORICA DEI MODELLI DI CONOSCENZA CONSENTA DI COMPRENDERE LE STRUTTURE PROFONDE DEI PROCESSI COGNITIVI E DI ORIENTARE LA PROGETTAZIONE DIDATTICA VERSO PRATICHE DI INDAGINE AUTENTICAMENTE FORMATIVE. IL PRIMO CAPITOLO RICOSTRUISCE LA GENEALOGIA DELLE PRINCIPALI FORME DELLA RAZIONALITÀ SCIENTIFICA, DALL’ANTICHITÀ GRECO-ELLENISTICA ALLA SCIENZA MODERNA E AL PLURALISMO EPISTEMOLOGICO CONTEMPORANEO, ANALIZZANDO DIVERSI MODI DI ARTICOLARE IL RAPPORTO TRA OSSERVAZIONE, MODELLIZZAZIONE, FORMALIZZAZIONE E GIUSTIFICAZIONE TEORICA. IL METODO SCIENTIFICO EMERGE COME ESITO DI TRASFORMAZIONI CONCETTUALI E ONTOLOGICHE, NON COME PROCEDURA NEUTRA E ATEMPORALE. IL SECONDO CAPITOLO ESAMINA LE PRINCIPALI TRADIZIONI DELL’EDUCAZIONE SCIENTIFICA DEL NOVECENTO, DA DEWEY A BRUNER, INTERPRETANDOLE COME MODELLI DI RAZIONALITÀ EDUCATIVA FONDATI SULLA COSTRUZIONE ATTIVA E SOCIALMENTE MEDIATA DEL SAPERE. IN TALE QUADRO VENGONO DISCUSSI I MODELLI IBSE, MER E MEDS COME CORNICI INTEGRATIVE PER LA PROGETTAZIONE DIDATTICA. IL TERZO CAPITOLO ANALIZZA PERCORSI LABORATORIALI DI FISICA PROGETTATI SECONDO LOGICHE DI INQUIRY E MODELLIZZAZIONE, MOSTRANDO COME LE OPERAZIONI EPISTEMICHE STORICAMENTE EMERSE, PROBLEMATIZZAZIONE, OSSERVAZIONE, IDEALIZZAZIONE, MODELLIZZAZIONE, FORMALIZZAZIONE, VERIFICA E REVISIONE DELLE IPOTESI, RIEMERGANO NEI PROCESSI DI APPRENDIMENTO DEGLI STUDENTI. LA TESI SOSTIENE CHE EDUCAZIONE SCIENTIFICA E SVILUPPO STORICO DELLA CONOSCENZA CONDIVIDONO ARCHITETTURE COGNITIVE OMOLOGHE, RADICATE ANCHE NELLA FILOGENESI DELLA MENTE UMANA, E PROPONE UNA CONCEZIONE DELLA DIDATTICA DELLA FISICA COME EDUCAZIONE ALLA RAZIONALITÀ CRITICA.
IL METODO SCIENTIFICO TRA STORIA, METODOLOGIE ED APPLICAZIONI IN AULA.
Lamberti, Veruska
2026
Abstract
ABSTRACT, ENGLISH VERSION THE DISSERTATION EXAMINES THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD AS A HISTORICALLY DETERMINED FORM OF RATIONALITY AND AS A PEDAGOGICAL RESOURCE FOR PHYSICS EDUCATION, INTEGRATING PERSPECTIVES FROM THE HISTORY OF SCIENCE, EPISTEMOLOGY, AND EDUCATIONAL SCIENCES. THE AIM IS TO SHOW HOW THE HISTORICAL RECONSTRUCTION OF MODELS OF KNOWLEDGE MAKES IT POSSIBLE TO UNDERSTAND THE DEEP STRUCTURES OF COGNITIVE PROCESSES AND TO GUIDE INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN TOWARD GENUINELY INQUIRY-BASED EDUCATIONAL PRACTICES. THE FIRST CHAPTER RECONSTRUCTS THE GENEALOGY OF THE MAIN FORMS OF SCIENTIFIC RATIONALITY, FROM GRECO-HELLENISTIC ANTIQUITY TO MODERN SCIENCE AND CONTEMPORARY EPISTEMOLOGICAL PLURALISM, ANALYZING DIFFERENT WAYS OF ARTICULATING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN OBSERVATION, MODELING, FORMALIZATION, AND THEORETICAL JUSTIFICATION. THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD THUS EMERGES AS THE OUTCOME OF CONCEPTUAL AND ONTOLOGICAL TRANSFORMATIONS, RATHER THAN AS A NEUTRAL AND TIMELESS PROCEDURE. THE SECOND CHAPTER EXAMINES THE MAIN TRADITIONS OF SCIENCE EDUCATION IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY, FROM DEWEY TO BRUNER, INTERPRETING THEM AS MODELS OF EDUCATIONAL RATIONALITY GROUNDED IN THE ACTIVE AND SOCIALLY MEDIATED CONSTRUCTION OF KNOWLEDGE. WITHIN THIS FRAMEWORK, THE MODELS OF IBSE, MER, AND MEDS ARE DISCUSSED AS INTEGRATIVE APPROACHES TO INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN. THE THIRD CHAPTER ANALYZES PHYSICS LABORATORY ACTIVITIES DESIGNED ACCORDING TO INQUIRY- AND MODELING-BASED APPROACHES, SHOWING HOW HISTORICALLY ESTABLISHED EPISTEMIC OPERATIONS,PROBLEMATIZATION, OBSERVATION, IDEALIZATION, MODELING, FORMALIZATION, AND THE TESTING AND REVISION OF HYPOTHESES, RE-EMERGE IN STUDENTS’ LEARNING PROCESSES. THE DISSERTATION ARGUES THAT SCIENCE EDUCATION AND THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE SHARE HOMOLOGOUS COGNITIVE ARCHITECTURES, ALSO ROOTED IN THE PHYLOGENESIS OF THE HUMAN MIND, AND PROPOSES A CONCEPTION OF PHYSICS TEACHING AS EDUCATION IN CRITICAL RATIONALITY.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Abstract Lamberti Veruska PDF A.pdf
embargo fino al 21/01/2027
Licenza:
Tutti i diritti riservati
Dimensione
359.93 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
359.93 kB | Adobe PDF | |
|
tesi_di_dottorato VERUSKA LAMBERTI PDF A.pdf
embargo fino al 21/01/2027
Licenza:
Tutti i diritti riservati
Dimensione
1.46 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.46 MB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14242/385485
URN:NBN:IT:UNISA-385485