In today's rapidly evolving business environment, artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming the way organizations generate value and make strategic decisions. In response, this doctoral dissertation investigates how AI reshapes top managers' strategic leadership and managerial decision-making across organizational levels. Drawing primarily on Upper Echelons Theory and a strategic leadership perspective, the dissertation addresses the growing need to understand how AI, particularly generative AI, transforms the cognitive, relational, organizational, and ethical foundations of executives' work. Structured as a collection of four research papers, it combines systematic literature review, qualitative empirical research, and a conceptual approach. The first study consolidates the fragmented literature on AI and top managers' leadership through bibliometric and content analyses, identifying key research themes and future directions. The second study explores, through interviews with senior executives, how different forms of AI reshape the strategic leadership skills required of top managers, identifying four interdependent skills: AI open mindset, AI strategic co-thinker, multi-level connector, and ethics risk management. The third study adopts a multi-echelon perspective to examine how generative AI reconfigures decision-making boundaries between top and middle managers, showing how the timing of managerial involvement and opportunities to challenge AI-generated strategic alternatives shape interpretive influence and verification responsibilities without necessarily altering formal decision authority. The fourth study develops a conceptual framework explaining how generative AI reshapes strategic leadership functions through synthetic strategic knowledge, highlighting the associated epistemic risks and positioning Human–GenAI collaboration as a moderating mechanism between executive characteristics and strategic leadership functions. Together, the studies provide an integrated account of how AI reshapes executive cognition, strategic leadership functions, and cross-level decision-making processes, while emphasizing the importance of critical evaluation and epistemic governance when AI-generated knowledge informs strategic choices. In doing so, the dissertation advances Upper Echelons Theory and a multi-echelon understanding of strategic leadership in the AI era, offering insights into how organizations can integrate AI-generated knowledge into strategic decision-making while preserving human judgment, accountability, and meaningful cross-level collaboration.
Artificial Intelligence and Top Managers: An Upper Echelons Theory Perspective on Strategic Leadership and Decision-Making across Organizational Levels
BEVILACQUA, SIMONE
2026
Abstract
In today's rapidly evolving business environment, artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming the way organizations generate value and make strategic decisions. In response, this doctoral dissertation investigates how AI reshapes top managers' strategic leadership and managerial decision-making across organizational levels. Drawing primarily on Upper Echelons Theory and a strategic leadership perspective, the dissertation addresses the growing need to understand how AI, particularly generative AI, transforms the cognitive, relational, organizational, and ethical foundations of executives' work. Structured as a collection of four research papers, it combines systematic literature review, qualitative empirical research, and a conceptual approach. The first study consolidates the fragmented literature on AI and top managers' leadership through bibliometric and content analyses, identifying key research themes and future directions. The second study explores, through interviews with senior executives, how different forms of AI reshape the strategic leadership skills required of top managers, identifying four interdependent skills: AI open mindset, AI strategic co-thinker, multi-level connector, and ethics risk management. The third study adopts a multi-echelon perspective to examine how generative AI reconfigures decision-making boundaries between top and middle managers, showing how the timing of managerial involvement and opportunities to challenge AI-generated strategic alternatives shape interpretive influence and verification responsibilities without necessarily altering formal decision authority. The fourth study develops a conceptual framework explaining how generative AI reshapes strategic leadership functions through synthetic strategic knowledge, highlighting the associated epistemic risks and positioning Human–GenAI collaboration as a moderating mechanism between executive characteristics and strategic leadership functions. Together, the studies provide an integrated account of how AI reshapes executive cognition, strategic leadership functions, and cross-level decision-making processes, while emphasizing the importance of critical evaluation and epistemic governance when AI-generated knowledge informs strategic choices. In doing so, the dissertation advances Upper Echelons Theory and a multi-echelon understanding of strategic leadership in the AI era, offering insights into how organizations can integrate AI-generated knowledge into strategic decision-making while preserving human judgment, accountability, and meaningful cross-level collaboration.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tesi-Bevilacqua-Simone.pdf
embargo fino al 13/11/2029
Licenza:
Tutti i diritti riservati
Dimensione
11.22 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
11.22 MB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14242/385672
URN:NBN:IT:UNITO-385672