Old and new methods in geometric morphometrics applied to the study of human evolution: case studies

The main aim of this thesis is the application of Geometric Morphometric methods on different case-studies for the study of human evolution. When combined with techniques of acquisition of 3D models, Geometric Morphometrics allows us: - to investigate different experimental designs; - to analyse the interaction of several aspects on morphological adaptations detected within taxon-specific studies (e.g., allometry, phylogenetic signal, functional factors); - to study fragmentary fossils and incomplete specimens, through estimation of missing data and 3D virtual restoration (e.g., surface and curve slid semilandmark); - to plan, code and test new algorithms and/or methodological approaches. The first part deals with the use of smoothing filters applied to 3D model for Geometric Morphometric studies. These algorithms are used to remove the background noise deriving from digital acquisition (e.g., photogrammetry, laser scan and computerized tomography scan). The effects of the different smoothing filters have been assessed. In particular have been defined guidelines for a correct use of these algorithms, besides the developing of an automatized tool, in R environment, to find the best combination between algorithm type, settings and number of iterations. The second part consists of a protocol developed, with the collaboration of the University of Freiburg, for the digital retrodeformation of fossil specimens showing evidence of shearing, bending and compressing alterations due to taphonomic processes. Traditional methods of retrodeformation only use a sparse set of bilateral landmarks; the number of points appears to affects the success of retrodeformation. On the contrary, this method uses, in addition to the landmark configurations, the curve and surface semilandmarks, which allow us to capture morphological information more accurately. This protocol was applied here to the neanderthalian cranium of Saccopastore 1. The third part reports the results of the first analysis on the specimen nicknamed "Pàus” (St.n.166623), recently discovered near Spinadesco in the Po Valley (Northern Italy). A set of 100 semilandmarks was built on the specimen and slid, using a set of 6 landmark, on a comparative sample including specimens dated to the Middle-to-Late Pleistocene. The results show how the morphology of “Pàus” is consistent with the variability observed in the Neanderthal lineage. The fourth part concerns a Geometric Morphometric investigation performed on two human cranial fossil remains from Melka Kunture, dated to about 850 ka. The two cranial fragments consist in a partial left parietal (MK73/GOM II- 6769; formally Melka Kunture 1, or MK1) and a right portion of the frontal bone (MK76/GOM II - 576, or MK2). Specifically, evenly-spaced semilandmark sets were used acquired along the sagittal suture and the inferior temporal line on MK1 and MK2 respectively. The results of the analyses, in agreement with the chronology of the fossils, represent at present, evidence of one of the best candidates to be the most ancient example of H. heidelbergensis. The fifth part treats with the external morphology of the cranial base in extant and living Hominoids in relation to ontogenetic, allometric, locomotor and phylogenetic factors. The sample selected consists of 3D landmark configurations acquired on specimens (male and female) including infant, sub-adult and adult individuals. The centroid size of the landmark set configuration was used as indicator of size while the pattern of dental eruption (at death) was used to define six age groups. The relation between morphology and locomotion was explored through the estimation of the position of the foramen magnum along the Frankfurt plane. Finally, a phylogenetic tree was build using molecular and paleontological data, with the phylogenetic signal investigated through centroid size and shape.